Has Your Child Earned All Freedoms?

Source: www.noisycoworkers.com

The idea that our kids need to earn their freedoms is so crucial to the Babywise way of raising our kids. We cannot give our kids certain freedoms without making sure they can handle those freedoms.

How do we determine whether we should allow a certain freedom? Many parents award freedoms based on the child’s age. We think, He’s 5 now. He’s old enough to cross the street without holding my hand. Or she’s 7 now. She should be old enough to take care of a pet. But do we stop to actually think about the child’s level of responsibility? Is the 5-year-old responsible enough to stop and look both ways before crossing the street every single time? Is the 7-year-old responsible enough to fill a pet’s food and water bowls and do it every day without reminders?

When we decide whether our kids have earned certain freedoms, we should determine whether they are responsible enough, not old enough. You might even find that your younger child is more responsible in certain areas than your older child. It’s perfectly normal.

Before I get into certain types of freedoms we should evaluate, let me take a minute to explain why this is so important. Essentially, our kids need to learn how to make decisions. And to learn anything, we need to take baby steps. To open the world up to a child and allow him to choose everything from what shirt he wears to whether he’ll do his homework is just too much for a young child. This is how the Ezzos put it:

“[There is] a legitimate concern that warns against creating the false impression in the mind of a child that she is able to do anything, say anything, and go anywhere without parental guidance or approval. Simply put, this is a child who has been granted too many freedoms of self-governance too early, and this is how children become ‘wise in their own eyes.’ It is our firm conviction, based on our observations, that more conflicts arise out of this ‘wise in your own eyes’ attitude than any other single factor in parenting,'” (Growing Kids God’s Way, p. 180).

Pretty powerful stuff, huh? Let’s take a minute to look at a few areas of freedoms that we might be tempted to award our children without ensuring responsibility:

Physical Boundaries

I’ve been a long-time proponent of the idea that our kids should not be allowed to roam the house, no matter how old they are. When we allow our kids to roam the house, they get the idea that every room in the house and everything in it is there for the taking. Before we implemented this rule, William would root through my bathroom drawers, wander upstairs by himself, and even go into the backyard without asking permission. Now, my kids know they are to ask permission to go anywhere but the main downstairs area.

Now at age 8, William has earned the freedom to go upstairs without me, but he still tells me or checks in before he does. I’ll allow him to take a shower (upstairs) by himself. But I have to make sure Lucas doesn’t go with him. Lucas has not earned the freedom to be upstairs by himself or without a parent. If he’s up there with William, they often wreak havoc.

Time

As odd as this may sound, our kids need to earn the freedom to choose what to do with their time. Before they learn the value of managing time, our kids will certainly choose to play all day and not do a single chore or bit of homework. I’ll be the first to tell you that our kids certainly need time to play. It is through play that our kids learn. It is through the imagination (which flourishes in play) that our kids learn to be creative and think critically. But we need to manage our kids’ time for them so they learn the value of time management. They need to learn that it’s usually far better to get your work done first and then play.

Plus, if you’ve been a Babywise parent, you’ve learned that directing our kids’ lives is so beneficial to their development. Keeping them on a schedule and directing their time tells our kids that they don’t get to choose to do whatever they want whenever they want. They learn that they are held accountable to the parents’ expectations.

Play

Yes, our kids need to earn freedoms when it comes to play. There are many aspects of my kids’ playtime that I direct:

1) Sibling playtime

2) Independent playtime

3) Play with friends and neighbors

4) Outdoor play

5) Exercise through play

6) Video game play

My kids are allowed free play, but I will tell them when it’s time to play outside, when it’s time to ride their bikes, and when it’s time to play with friends. And they must earn freedoms and show responsibility even when it comes to play. During free play, they are not allowed to trash the playroom. I don’t limit the amount of toys they can have out at once. But they have earned this freedom simply because they know they need to put toys away as they go.

Sibling playtime is also a freedom they need to continually prove responsibility for. If they say nasty things to each other or don’t share, they lose the freedom to play with each other. And for my boys, this is one of the most severe punishments I can give. My boys love each other so much and hate playing alone.

Playtime with friends is also a freedom my boys need to earn. There are always kids out playing on our street (when the weather isn’t too bad). And many of them will come to the door to invite my kids out. I allow my kids to go when the neighbors are out, but I watch their play closely. If one of my boys speaks rudely to another child, I’ll give a warning. If it happens again, I make the child play by himself or go in the house. Playing with friends is a skill they need to learn, and I’m not going to just let them figure it out on their own.

And as you might guess, I limit video game play quite a bit. It’s only allowed on the weekends, and my boys need to have cleaned up their toys before they are allowed to play. If the video games cause anger or violence in the child, I turn it off. They need to learn how to play video games and not let it negatively affect their disposition.

These are probably the top three areas where we find we need to limit our kids’ freedoms. Think through each one to determine whether your child has any freedoms he needs to earn. If you have given a freedom that the child hasn’t earned, don’t be afraid to take it away. Our kids go through phases where they are responsible for a certain freedom and then they stop being so responsible. Freedoms come and go with the child’s level of responsibility.

Comments

  1. I totally agree with these and the whole “wise in your eyes” attitude. Time and time again i think the root of a lot of issues is this and too many choices “the toddler choice addition” in the earlier books but it applies throughout. Anyways I recognize that and work on that. I think tempermanent is a factor. My DD2 is more spirited by nature and maybe from birth order has learned a lot on her own (vs the older who tends to ask for more help) and a lot of “let me do that” or “I know that”,etc. We are working on tone and acceptable ways to speak. I am giving a red button for poor tone instead of blue for good tone and manners and that is helping. But we have issues with clothes! And this seems common with girls. Since you have boys maybe this doens’t apply and you don’t know but it’s a battle. I am not willing to have clothing battles at age 4 as who knows what the teen years will be! Went through this with DD1 a bit a while ago. She always wanted the same clothes and would argue. I would give 2 choices but it was always another choice she’d try. So I ended up taking all the clothes away except a few and told her when she stopped arguing and complaining/whining and showing me should could handle it i would keep the clothes. After the intial fit it worked. A rare reminder is needed here or there but it was very effective. Now dd2 is a different story. She is a “negotiator”. Always trying to negotiate things,etc. I point it out to DH a lot as i think it runs through her behaviour in all areas. If i give 2 choices it’s always another, We have fits about clothes 1/2 the week. I have taken her clothes away, she’s earned them back but then starts again. If she is very argumentative I say “I’m sorry you lost the decision today. Mommy is deciding the clothes today” and she’ll pitch a fit but does come downstairs eventually wearing them. It’s just we have to listen to 10 minutes of a fit or yelling to me,etc (which i ignore). It’s annoying. In general with her I feel like I go around in circles. It seems like we have a lot of the same issues over and over. Maybe it’s a normal thing at this age?? or in part her testing personality?? I recall times with DD1 where i wondered sometimes if i was making headway but she’s 6 now and in kindergarten and overall very good behaviour so i know the long-term perspective is probably ok:) I just wonder if i’m doing something wrong. I feel like probably am. I never had the Moms Notes on Freedoms and Wise in your Eyes. Do you consider them real helpful? I have all the wise books and FTO so i may be ok. The whole thing about freedoms if hard as i wonder sometimes if i give enough,etc but on the other hand i think the root is usually too much vs too little, especially at the younger ages. i know it changes but i’m not sure when. again i think at the preschooler age or even young school age it probably is not too little. They say if they don’t have enough they get frustrated but I think the arguing, whining, complaining is a sign of too much. Do you agree? That is what my gut says. I think for my oldest (who is 6) i will run the potential risk of letting her have freedoms a bit late and the youngest ones have them earlier than they should…obviously i am mindful of it but i just mean i can see how parents unwittingly fall into that. Anyways just curious your thoughts and one the clothes thing. I think it is a girl thing!:)

Speak Your Mind